[Retros] feenschach award cook

[Henrik Juel]

The awards for the informal tourney in feenschach 1997/98 were recently 
posted on the RetroCorner. The problem by Frolkin & Kornilov receiving a 
commendation seems cooked. I would have preferred to contact the authors 
directly, but I don't have their adresses.

8/8/8/P2PP1PP/RPPrRbrB/QpKpp1p1/b4p1p/kNn5 (13+12)

. . . . . . . .    Andrej Frolkin & Andrej Kornilov
. . . . . . . .    Commended, feenschach 1997/98
. . . . . . . . 
o . . o o . o o 
R o o r R b r B 
Q + K + + . + . 
b . . . . + . + 
k N n . . . . .    #1 (who)

In the intended retroplay White starts: -1.Nd2 c2-c1=N -2.Nf3 Kb1 -3.Ng1 
Ka1 -4.Nh3 f3 -5.Nf2 Kb1 -6.Nd1 Kc1 -7.Nb2 Bb1 -8.Qa1 h3 -9.Ra2 Kd1 
-10.Na4 etc., so Black has the move and mates by 1.. Ne2#.
The RetroCorner reports a complicated try where Black starts the 
retroplay; but this possibility still seems feasible, with a simple 
retroplay: -1.. c2-c1=N -2.Qc1 f3 -3.Qd2 h3 -4.Na3 Kb1 -5.Nb5 etc., 
where White has the move and mates by 1.Qb2#.
Did I overlook something?

Henrik
--
Henrik Juel. Informatics and Mathematical Modelling, Building 321,
Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Kongens Lyngby, Denmark.
http://www.imm.dtu.dk/~hj  Phone +45 4525 3391  Fax +45 4593 2373