[Retros] Plaksin-Zolotarev problem (diagrammes, 109) Cooked?

[Joost de Heer]

> N. Plaksin and A. Zolotarev

> diagrammes 109, 04/1994 (3100)

>> 1st Prize, diagrammes 1993-94

>> [QN2b3/rrpnPp2/1RK1pb2/1B6/P1k5/1nP1P1P1/2PP1P1b/3N4]

>> 14+11. Promotions took place after White's e2-e3. Release the position.



> In this proofgame there are ony three Ceriani-Frolkin promotions, two Q and

> one R:


In your proofgame, there are promotions before e2-e3. So this is no cook. You probably misinterpreted the stipulation. It should be interpreted as 'All promotions...'.

Joost
-- 
______________________________________________
http://www.linuxmail.org/
Now with e-mail forwarding for only US$5.95/yr

Powered by Outblaze